We Are Now Open
Sun & Mon By Appointment Only !

If you are coming from a distance to buy or sell we can help you set a date .
If you live local and plan on shopping or looking for cash on something we can set a time.

Selling & Spending Must Be $100 Or More To Set A Appointment

Send A Private ...

Read More


Celebrating 16,000 Likes

A Free Gift For Being Apart Of Our Family !

To enter: 🦸🏻‍♂️Like & follow Toying Around 💪Tag friends in comments below.
🤖Share this post.

Winner gets: Hasbro Marvel Legen...

Read More

Get Cash For Your New & Used,
Toys, Comics, Collectibles, Trading Cards & Video Games !
Message Us Now For A Free Quote !
#johnstownny #upstateny #capitalregion #albanyny #fultoncountyny #adirondacks #toyingaround #toyingaroundapparel #toystore #videogamestore #tradingcardstore #comicbookshop #a...

Read More

If You’re Looking To Shop For Christmas,
Look No Further Then The Best Toy Store In Upstate NY !
Toys, Comics, Collectibles, Trading Cards, Video Games & So Much More !

Open Tue-Fri 10-6pm Sat 10-4pm
Sun-Mon Closed
17 West Main St Johnstown NY
(518) 795-9410
ToyingAroundJohnstownNY@gmail.com ...

Read More

Need Cash For The Holidays ?
Get Cash For Your New & Used,
Toys, Comics, Collectibles, Trading Cards & Video Games !
Message Us Now For A Free Quote !
#johnstownny #upstateny #capitalregion #albanyny #fultoncountyny #adirondacks #toyingaround #toyingaroundapparel #toystore #videogamestore #trad...

Read More

Toying Around Costume Contest
October 27
12pm 3pm 🍬🎃👻💵
During The Annual Harvest Festival & Kids Costume Parade!
Hosted By Deadpool
Stop In , Sign Up , Shop, Get Candy, Take A Picture With Deadpool!
Kids $50 Cash
Adults $30 Cash
Winners will be selected & called after 3:00pm

Read More
Learn more


a month ago
I would recommend going to Toying Around has lots of figures , comics , and pops. The store is huge has tons of awesome stuff if you are reading this review I would go to toying around
- The k
5 months ago
Great store, staff, items and prices. Always welcoming and helpful. The best is the way they treat customers with little things like a freeze pop or just chit chatting away with a five year old that is excited about whatever and they are just as excited to talk with him. Always helpful cause I'm clueless about a lot of things. Keep up the awesomeness and we will by the way always shop n enjoy your shop. Kuddos
- Pam M
5 months ago
I haven’t got any more room in my house for collectibles, but if i did, I’d buy them from here. There’s a ton of stuff, and the staff didn’t at all mind when my (at the time) 1.5 year old daughter fiddled around with the donkey Kong arcade machine. Friendly people, sweet to kiddos, and always a joy at the local comic cons 🥇
- Melanie B

Contact Us


Call now
  • (518) 795-9410


Get directions
17 West Main Street
Johnstown, NY 12095

Business Hours

Tue:10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Wed:10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Thu:10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Fri:10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Sat:10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Contact Us
Message sent. We'll get back to you soon.