Updates

GATHERINGS & CONVENTIONS MAY BE ON HOLD !
SO ITS TIME TO PLAN YOUR NEXT ROAD TRIP
THE BEST TOY STORE IN UPSTATE NY

Established in 2012, Toying Around is a family owned and operated real brick & mortar toy store specializing in buying/selling action figures, video games, trading cards, comic bo...

Read More

Are you a fan of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles ?

Looking for something radical to add to your next event?

Bring some Turtle Power with #toyingaroundmikey๐Ÿข๐Ÿ•

Available For:
Parties
Charities
Conventions
Business Events & More !

Book Now:
ToyingAroundJohnstownNY@gmail.com
(518) 795-9410

Why not both !
We are the best place to get a new unwrapped toy for a donation to both of these great local organizations this holiday season !
Capital Region Toys for Tots
The Salvation Army of Fulton County, NY.

Itโ€™s the best
TOY STORE IN UPSTATE NY
Start your holiday shopping with us !
๐ŸŽ…๐Ÿปโ›„๏ธ๐ŸŽ๐ŸŽ„
Need extra cash for more holiday shopping?
WE BUY TOYS !
We buy any size collection of VINTAGE and MODERN action figures, used or new in package.
No Appointment needed!
You can bring them in today to sell! ...

Read More

Testimonials

3 months ago
Sold part of my Transformers collection. Process was extremely fair. They went through every piece and appraised them carefully. Both boxed and opened. Explained the process of determining value and paid cash. Went smoothly and I feel I got a good price. I would highly recommend trading in with them!
- Dana R
a month ago
Recently traded in some collectibles at the store, the process was more than fair and the owner explained price points clearly! I would highly recommend stopping in and buying some merchandise, there is something for all ages!
- Brandon S
a week ago
Love the place very friendly staff, lots vintage toys clean and is reasonable price to buy I always love going to this when I come from NYC A most place too see.
- Classic g

Contact Us

Contact

Call now
  • (518) 795-9410

Address

Get directions
17 West Main Street
Johnstown, NY 12095
USA

Business Hours

Mon:Closed
Tue:10:00 AM โ€“ 6:00 PM
Wed:10:00 AM โ€“ 6:00 PM
Thu:10:00 AM โ€“ 6:00 PM
Fri:10:00 AM โ€“ 6:00 PM
Sat:10:00 AM โ€“ 4:00 PM
Sun:Closed
Get quote
โœ•
Message sent. We'll get back to you soon.